Stephanie Duncan Smith – Even After Everything [Feature Review]
Returning to Love, Again A Feature Review of Even After Everything: The Spiritual Practice of Knowing the Risks and Loving […]
New Book Releases – Week of 28 October 2024 – Norman Wirzba, more…
Here are a few new book releases from this week that are worth checking out… (Where possible, we have also […]
Lectionary Poetry – 24th Sunday After Pentecost ( Year B )
We offer here a broad selection of classic and contemporary poems from diverse poets that stir our imaginations with thoughts […]
Ten Theology Books to Watch For – October 2024
Here are some excellent new theology books * that will be released in October 2024 : * broadly interpreted, including […]
Chigozie Obioma – The Road to the Country [Feature Review]
Ambitious, Altering and Admirable A Feature Review of The Road to the Country: A NovelChigozie Obioma Hardcover: Hogarth, 2024Buy Now: […]
Latest News
Ebook Deal of the Day! Joan Chittister – Wisdom Distilled from the Daily – $2.99
Our Kindle Ebook Deal of the Day… Wisdom Distilled from the Daily: Living the Rule of St. Benedict Today by […]
Brad Roth – Flyover Church [Review]
Paying Attention to the Margins in Rural America A Review of Flyover Church: How Jesus’ Ministry In Rural Places Is […]
Ben Lansing and D.J. Marotta – Our Church Speaks [Excerpt]
Read an excerpt from this excellent new book… Our Church Speaks: An Illustrated Devotional of Saints from Every Era and […]
Ebook Deal of the Day! Hannah Arendt – Antisemitism – $3.99
Our Kindle Ebook Deal of the Day… Antisemitism: Part One of The Origins of Totalitarianism by Hannah Arendt *** $3.99 […]
Ebook Deal of the Day! C.S. Lewis – George MacDonald – $1.99
Our Kindle Ebook Deal of the Day… George MacDonald by C.S. Lewis *** $1.99 *** [ Buy Now ] […]
By Joan Chittister
Latest Deals:
Ebook Deal of the Day! William Cavanaugh – Being Consumed – $3.99
5 Essential Ebook Deals for Church Leaders – 24 October 2024
Most viewed.
- Rumi Poems – Eight of Our Favorites by the Sufi Mystic 341462 views
- Ten Best Abraham Lincoln Biographies 131949 views
- Hafez Poems – Eight of Our Favorites from the Divan of Hafez ( In English ) 106457 views
- Walt Whitman Poems – 8 of our Favorites from Leaves of Grass 98538 views
- Alexander Pushkin – Eight Favorite Poems by the Russian Poet 90348 views
- Lent – Seven of our Favorite Poems 61647 views
- Against Christian Nationalism: Essential Books [A Reading Guide] 53373 views
- Ten Important Women Theologians To Start Reading 47301 views
- Hilarious One-Star Bible Reviews 45227 views
- Dallas Willard Books – Seven Essential Titles to Read! 43466 views
- Ten Best Alexander Hamilton Biographies 41486 views
- John O’Donohue Poems – Four of our Favorites 40864 views
- Best Bob Dylan Books – Biographies, Lyrics, and More! 40287 views
- November – Eight Classic Poems! 35682 views
- Classic Gratitude Poems – Joy Harjo, Mary Oliver, MORE 35417 views
- Wendell Berry Poems – Seven of Our Favorites! 30419 views
- Thomas Merton Books – An Intro Reading Guide 30266 views
- St. Augustine – Three Poems 28405 views
- N.T. Wright Books – An Introductory Reading Guide to The Theologian’s Work 28318 views
- Antiracism Books for Christians – A Reading Guide 27914 views
- Eastern Orthodoxy – Essential Books [A Reading List] 25787 views
- Joy Harjo Poems – Five of the Best Poems by the Former US Poet Laureate 25547 views
- Fyodor Dostoevsky – Download all his Novels as Free Ebooks !!! 24652 views
- Mary Oliver Essays – 10 Prose Selections to Read for Free Online! 24150 views
- Holy Sonnets – John Donne – Complete Text 23537 views
- Twelve Important Theology Books of 2021!!! 23493 views
- Emily Dickinson Poems – Seven of our Favorites! 23166 views
- Jami – Eight Poems by the Sufi Poet 23052 views
- Fifteen Important Theology Books of 2022!!! 22394 views
- Best Leonard Cohen Books – Biographies and Books by the Songwriter 20146 views
- Gerard Manley Hopkins – 5 Favorite Poems 18635 views
- St. Augustine – Best Books on His Life and Work 18069 views
- Henri Nouwen Books – An Introductory Reading Guide 17910 views
- Robert Frost – 5 Lesser Known Poems 17884 views
- Marilynne Robinson – 10 Freely Available Essays! 17773 views
- Twelve Important Theology Books of 2020!!! 17470 views
- The Best C.S. Lewis Biography (And Other Biographies /Companion Guides)! 17170 views
- Frederick Buechner Books – An Introductory Reading Guide 17108 views
- Twelve Important Fiction Books of 2022! 17061 views
- 2023 Advent Calendar of the Year’s Best Books! 17052 views
- Anne Bradstreet Poems – Five of our Favorites by the Puritan Poet! 16817 views
- Spring 2021 Most Anticipated Books for Christian Readers! 16369 views
- Fifteen Important Theology Books of 2023! 16230 views
- Martin Luther King, Jr. – His Prophetic Faith in 15 Quotes 15715 views
- Sabbath Books – Best Reads for Christians on Rest and Sabbath! 15442 views
- Jacques Ellul Books – An Introductory Reading Guide 15379 views
- Best Johnny Cash Books – Biographies and More! 15137 views
- Spring 2023 – Most Anticipated Books for Christian Readers! 15127 views
- Willa Cather Short Stories – Five Superb Stories to Read for FREE! 14772 views
- Dorothy Sayers Poems – Five of Our Favorites! 14737 views
- Matsuo Basho – Five Haiku – Poetry 14105 views
- Howard Thurman – Books – An Introductory Reading Guide 14036 views
- John Wesley Sermons – The 7 Best Sermons from the Founder of Methodism! 13964 views
- On Being with Krista Tippett – Top 10 Best Episodes! 13730 views
- Spring 2024 – Most Anticipated Books for Christian Readers! 13343 views
Our Favorite Posts:
- > Rumi Poems
- > Hafez Poems
- > Joy Harjo Poems
- > Wendell Berry Poems
- > Dorothy Sayers Poems
The Englewood Review of Books
FREE Ebook! Reading for the Common Good by ERB Editor Chris Smith
A Pilgrim in Narnia
- C.S. Lewis and the Love of Words
- Join us for “Reading Anne of Green Gables as Fantasy”: November SPACE Short Course
It’s a “Go” for Launch! I am taking Anne of Green Gables to SPACE once again in November!
Last fall, I taught “ Reading L.M. Montgomery as Fantasy: Anne of Green Gables ,” and it was one of my favourite teaching experiences ever. It is an idea that I have wanted to test for a while: rereading the iconic Anne of Green Gables as if it were a fantasy book rather than as realistic youth fiction (as it has traditionally been sold). I ended up broadcasting from different places in the land of Anne, including her grandfather’s homestead. While I had a hunch that the material would work, I was amazed at how powerfully this approach transformed Anne of Green Gables for me as a reader.
So, we are offering “AGG as Fantasy” again in November, with a view to a similar approach in the future to Emily of New Moon , The Story Girl , or another Anne book ( Rainbow Valley , maybe?).
Click here to sign up or get more details: http://blackberry.signumuniversity.org/r/tNkb8W .
SPACE is an online, interactive, non-credit short course program for adult lifelong learning. It is quite an innovative program for folks who want to engage in great discussions and learn more about things they love. Classes are $100-$150, depending on how frequently you take the journey, and you can sign up here .
In the course description and video teaser below (where I sort of snuck into a National Park after hours), I make my pitch for why this short course could be really beneficial to first-time Anne readers and old friends of Green Gables.
I don’t know if my “Fantasy Anne Experiment” will create a revolution in literature or anything, but it is a chance to spend 8 classes over 4 weeks close-reading Anne of Green Gables and seeing a classic from a new angle.
Reading L.M. Montgomery as Fantasy: Part 1: Anne of Green Gables Precepted by Dr. Brenton Dickieson
Within weeks of its 1908 publication, L.M. Montgomery’s Anne of Green Gables became a bestseller. Over the years, this charming orphan story put Montgomery and her imaginative Prince Edward Island on a global map.
Despite the fact that Anne of Green Gables is Canada’s bestselling novel throughout the world—or because of it—Montgomery was ignored by the literati and scholarship. Montgomery was a public intellectual, the first female Canadian fellow of the Royal Society of Arts, and invested Officer of the Order of the British Empire. Still she was dismissed as “just” a children’s writer, a regionalist, or a woman. It was 25 years after Montgomery’s death before children’s literature and feminist scholars began to recover her work as worthy of study.
While there is a robust field of Montgomery scholarship, there are areas where our focus is sometimes too narrow. One of these is the category of “realistic” fiction. While there is a kind of verisimilitude about everyday life in the late Victorian era in her work, the realism is pressed to the margins of definition as Montgomery romanticizes the worlds she creates. And can we disagree that there is something magical about Anne herself? By changing our way of approach and by looking at Anne of Green Gables as a fantasy novel, what can we unveil in this classic novel?
Native Prince Edward Islander and Montgomery scholar Brenton Dickieson will lead students through a rereading of Anne of Green Gables using the lenses we use to study fantasy and speculative fiction with the goal of allowing one of the greatest living children’s books to live in new ways.
I believe in open access scholarship. Because of this, since 2011 I have made A Pilgrim in Narnia free with nearly 1,000 posts on faith, fiction, and fantasy. Please consider sharing my work so others can enjoy it.
- Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
- Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
- Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
- Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
- Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
- Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
- Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
- Click to print (Opens in new window)
- Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
- My Unblurbed Blurb of Charlie Starr’s The Lion Country
As I am between steps in the publication of a book about C.S. Lewis’s thought, I find myself coming back to my bookshelf with a bit of mental space. I have been following Charlie W. Starr’s work for almost as long as I have been blogging. I reviewed his ground-breaking book Light : C.S. Lewis’s First and Final Short Story , which launched his Lewis Handwriting Chart (LHC). Light and the LHC seemed to come at exactly the right time for me, and I tested out his in the archives over the next few years. In “ What Art is For: With C.S. Lewis and Dr. Charlie Starr ,” I had an opportunity to reflect upon what I am doing here on A Pilgrim in Narnia in dialogue with other artists-writers-critics. And as I talked about in my last post on “ The Other Side of Screwtape ,” I worked with him to publish an important piece of Lewis’s papers, the “Archangel Fragment.”
More than anything, I suppose, is that we have become friends. Charlie’s publisher, Kent State University Press, reached out to me for a blurb of The Lion Country , a companion to an earlier intriguing book about C.S. Lewis and myth: The Faun’s Bookshelf The request came at a point in my life where I was not capable of responding well. I read the book and wrote the blurb, but alas, I missed the publication deadline. Unfortunately, I still don’t have the ability to write a full review because there is more I want to say. Ch. 4, “The Apologetical Decade,” is breathtaking in its concision and clarity–though is new research that clarifies the timeline of Lewis’ spiritual journey to Christian faith. There is also something niggling me about one key aspect of Charlie’s argument.
Still, I would like to share how The Lion’s Country is a thoughtful discussion that helps readers dig deeper into Lewis’s life, work, and thought. Thus, for you dear reader, Still, I would like to share how The Lion’s Country is a thoughtful discussion that helps readers dig deeper into Lewis’s life, work, and thought. Thus, for you dear reader, I give you my unblurbed blurb–conscious of the lateness but not conscience-stricken!
The Faun’s Bookshelf by Charlie W. Starr (Kent State University Press, 2022)
Two of the great questions of human thought are tucked into many of the social debates of our generation: “What is really real?” and “How can I know what is true?” These questions were among C.S. Lewis’ central concerns–not just in his philosophical works but also in his literary criticism, popular essays, and world-famous, life-transforming fiction like The Chronicles of Narnia and The Screwtape Letters . Charlie Starr engages C.S. Lewis to address these critical questions of “epistemology” in a smart and accessible conversation in The Lion’s Country . Besides providing a resource for those who have been moved by Lewis’ life and works, The Lion’s Country equips everyday readers to resist two cultural pressures to equate “truth” with “reality.” On the one side are those who state that their scientific theory, moral belief, biblical interpretation, political ideology, historical understanding, or conspiracy theory simply is the truth. On the other side are those who reduce all truth and morality to their personal or cultural experience. A culture lost in either pathway will lead to what C.S. Lewis calls the “Abolition of Man,” the loss of our humanity in willing but unwitting slavery. In a winsome style and an earnest commitment to clarity, Charlie Starr offers readers an invitation to a deeper way of living that resists the thin worldviews of the popular imagination.
For more great reading, see these pieces:
Shedding Light on Lost Manuscripts: A Review of Charlie Starr’s “Light”
The Surprising Danger of Light
What Art is For: With C.S. Lewis and Dr. Charlie Starr
- The Other Side of Screwtape: C.S. Lewis’s “Archangel Fragment”
Have I talked about this super cool bit of research and writing yet? As I look through the Pilgrim in Narnia archive, I see a couple of hints of the “Archangel Fragment,” but not much more. In a cultural moment of bad news and social media warfare, I think it is time to share this full-on, totally invested, super fun bit of nerd news.
Back in the previous decade, before pandemics like COVID, AI, and digital duels about the Rings of Power, Charlie W. Starr sent me a message. I am friends with Charlie, so it was not startling to get a message from him. For context, though, I have been following Dr. Starr’s work for almost as long as I have been blogging. I reviewed his ground-breaking book Light: C.S. Lewis’s First and Final Short Story , which launched his Lewis Handwriting System (LHC). Light and the LHC came at exactly the right time for me, and over the next few years, I tested out his handwriting analysis system in the archives. Prof. Starr is the author of a pair of intriguing books about C.S. Lewis and myth: The Faun’s Bookshelf and The Lion’s Country . He’s also a teacher, novelist, hilarious Facebook poster, and publisher of a ridiculous amount of scholarly work.
This message was in the “Famous Handwriting Expert Dr. Charlie W. Starr” mode–the kind of message that makes even a friend sit up a little straighter in their chair:
Hi Brenton, Have you seen the angelic letter at the Bodleian, the one where Lewis attempts to write a letter from an archangel to a guardian angel (or some such)? It’s in one of the notebooks there.
As it turns out, I had seen this fragment in Lewis’s “Notebook V” (which I think of as the “Teastained Everything Book from the 1940s,” as pictured here). I had not honestly thought much about this bit of text and was not even certain if it was Lewis’s original composition or a quotation. As soon as Charlie pointed me in the right direction, though, I immediately saw what he was seeing:
C.S. Lewis once began an “Archangel Letter” as a response to The Screwtape Letters .
We need to back up a step or two–even for archive lovers, Lewis readers, and faithful visitors to A Pilgrim in Narnia.
While The Screwtape Letters was Lewis’s first bestselling book and provided him with a substantial audience for his writing, he sometimes minimized its value. He thought Perelandra was worth 20 Screwtapes and he found Screwtape painful to write. He even called it a literary “stunt.”
In the preface to a later addition to Screwtape’s archive of antispiritual advice, “Screwtape Proposes a Toast,” Lewis admitted that:
I had, moreover, a sort of grudge against my book [Screwtape] for not being a different book which no one could write. Ideally, Screwtape’s advice to Wormwood should have been balanced by archangelical advice to the patient’s guardian angel. Without this the picture of human life is lopsided.
To flaunt the deficits of one’s literary creation is a peculiar marketing device, but Lewis defends himself on his own challenge.
But who could supply the deficiency? Even if a man—and he would have to be a far better man than I—could scale the spiritual heights required, what “answerable style” could he use? For the style would really be part of the content. Mere advice would be no good; every sentence would have to smell of Heaven.
If he was bothered by the imbalance of Screwtape , why had Lewis not written The Michael Memos or Answer from an Archangel ? His answer: How could a mere mortal write such a thing? Considering his own life–which was one of the uncomfortable aspects of writing Screwtape –Lewis felt that he lacked the moral and spiritual capacity to write at such a level.
Lewis died three or four years after writing these words. As far as anyone knew, he had never expected to publish anything like The Seraphim Scribbles or Gabbing with Gabriel . Even in choosing a title, we can see how un-heavenly such a collection might be–even if the advice was angelically good.
Just because it was impossible, though, doesn’t mean Lewis didn’t try.
On fol. 63v of Notebook V, Lewis writes a paragraph that begins like this:
For this, my dear, is the true delight. To take a creature whom, if the King permitted and our own will were so strangely perverted, we could with one touch of the little finger turn into nothingness, even as that creature could spoil the down on a butterfly’s wing. . . .
The first sentence of this paragraph is 8 words; the second sentence continues on to 231 words. In that second sentence, each phrase lifts the language a step closer to a heavenly diction. As the imagery tumbles out, the meaning intensifies until there is nowhere else to go–at least in the limited grammar of authors after Eden.
I have touched up the quotation a bit for clarity, and you can find references in the linked paper. And I should warn you that I am going to turn all of this upside down at some point. But I have only shared a little excerpt from the full Archangel Fragment. I want you to join us in the discovery!
After clarifying the significance of this passage, Charlie and I worked together when I was in the Bodleian . Actually, in the Bod: I was in the Reading Room checking details, confirming our transcription, and seeing this celestial experiment in its context. The paper that resulted is “The Archangel Fragment and C.S. Lewis’s World-Building Project,” published in the 2019 edition of Sehnsucht: The C. S. Lewis Journal.
Blessedly, Sehnsucht journal is now open-source and available free to everyone. I provided the first few words of the Archangel Fragment as a teaser, but now you can read the entire fragment in the context of the argument Charlie and I made about C.S. Lewis as a writer about the spiritual life and creator of fictional worlds. I hope this is something you can enjoy and share–and respond to if you like–as Joe Ricke has done in his Sehnsucht piece, “ The Archangel Fragment: Identifying and Interpreting C. S. Lewis’s ‘Cryptic Note .'”
“The Archangel Fragment and C.S. Lewis’s World-Building Project” ( click here for the full paper)
In this article, we argue that, from a few hints in the Bodleian archive and elsewhere, we have discovered C. S. Lewis’s singular attempt at an Archangelic sequel to The Screwtape Letters. By analyzing this small fragment and its contextual clues, we can hear the heaven-scented voice of this anti-Screwtape world. Through this discovery we can unlock hidden links among Lewis’s fiction project of the late 1930s and early 1940s and the ways he created the speculative worlds of those stories, including a spirit of playfulness and discovery, themes critical to his theological perspective, and potential links that draw his 1937–1945 work together into a cohesive whole. Finally, considering this fragment provides an opportunity to test the Lewis Handwriting Chart and open possibilities for further archival research.
https://digitalcommons.georgefox.edu/cslewisjournal/vol13/iss1/2
Right now (in October, 2024), I am teaching a Signum SPACE course on C.S. Lewis’s archival material and writing habits. Click below for more information or follow the direct link here . It may be a program that interests you in the future!
- Ink Spots and Tea Stains: What We Learn from C.S. Lewis’s Writing Habits (October 2024 SPACE Course Announcement)
- Where Do We Find Meaning When We Read? A Spectrum of Discovery in Storytelling
Where is the meaning found in the art of reading ? Is it in the text itself–some magic of language or mystery of persuasion in the telling of a tale? Or do readers carry meaning in their own curiosity and willingness to undergo the quest? Is a story still a story without a reader? Can stories mean more than what their authors intended? Can there be a story that specifies only a certain interpretation of meaning while remaining a story? Can a story’s meaning change over time? Can we ever receive a story from another culture–time, place, language, or worldview–without creating new meaning?
As a teacher, reader, and critic, these questions are tremendously exciting. However, I have found that too many of these conversations are unnecessarily confusing. Sometimes, the debate is cloaked in the obscure, mercurial echoes of aitiocidal French criticism; at other times, common sense is wiped out by movements to defend or redefine the primacy of the text.
And, don’t you think this nebulous scene is worsened by the neologophilic nature of literary theory conversations? Like how I made up the word “neologophilic” to describe an unnatural love of making up new words (literally from Greek words meaning “new-word loving”). Or how I invented “aitiocidal” (also from Greek, an “aitiocide” would be a “source-killer” or “author-killer”) to describe the “Death of the Author” moment in terms that suggest the “Murder of the Author.” Honestly, I struggle with the terms. When I talk about the methods and means of reading and writing about literature, I have to bring out a spreadsheet to make it through the term-happy terrain.
Thus, for the sake of honesty about what we are doing–and as a tool I can use for teaching and reading–3 or 4 years ago, I made this little spectrum chart. I sketched it out during a conference as I struggled to shape some layperson language for the relationship between texts and readers. Spectrum thinking is inherently limited by a two-dimensional spread, but I will address some third-dimensional thinking another time.
This little chart moves along a spectrum of direct to indirect (left to right). Perspectives on the left show the movement out from the text to the reader; on the right, we see the dialogue between the text and reader from the reader’s point of view. It is tempting to think of this as a spectrum from “literal” to “metaphorical” storytelling, but that does not work if we want to be honest about what we are doing.
On the very left, perhaps we can use the word “literal” to describe a text that speaks directly to its readers about morality, truth, religion, spirituality, politics, ethics, science, love, sexuality, gender, home, land, the future, or whatever meaning an author would want to describe, symbolize, or intimate in a text. In Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged , there is a 3-hour speech recorded word for word about the philosophy that is presented in the novel. That speech, though, is not always “literal” as it uses metaphors, similes, and other symbolic and rhetorical tools. “Direct” is a better word: The “Text Points to the Path” that the author wants us to understand. Atlas Shrugged also “Symbolizes the Path” in that the plot (and character journey) is about what the novel is about. Moreover, the “Text Invites to the Path” as Atlas Shrugged creates a vision of courageous, risk-taking, hard-working wealthy business people retreating to a mountainside resort as America burns because of its unwillingness to make unrestrained commercial activity the centre of its constitutional reality.
We can see the (more or less) direct pointing to the path in less political texts. In our “ Canada Reads ” contest each year, it is clear that the short-listed texts are increasingly about something: immigration, indigeneity, gender, independence and relationality, coming of digital age, and a constant redefinition of what Canada “is.” A 1990s version of myself standing bewildered in front of a Christian fiction bookshelf would have called these 21st-century novels “preachy.” Moralistic art is hard to do well, but the Canada Reads contest both shapes and reveals Canada’s moral moment along the spectrum.
Narnia, too, has this sort of spread. At points the text teaches directly, like when Aslan describes the kind of character a king must develop in himself . Sometimes, Narnia symbolizes the path to meaning, like the turning of winter to spring and the death and resurrection of Aslan in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe . And Narnia is an invitational world: Life-giving characteristics like wonder, joy, clear-thinking, wisdom, and insight are there for the reader whether or not they share Lewis’s understanding of creation and the Creator.
From the other direction, the reader brings their questions, curiosities, cares, and concerns to the text. We can’t help doing it, really–though there is a case to be made for how best to receive a story (which I will make another day). My limitations of language, my cultural expectations, my faith, hope, and dreams, my literary imagination–all of these things are part of my experience as a reader in shaping meaning. And, sometimes, I do this more intentionally–reading a book to critique it, rewrite it, or find myself somewhere in it.
Philip Pullman ‘s His Dark Materials trilogy is an example for me. I don’t know if these Golden Compass books quite get to the far left of direct teaching, but it comes close. Lyra ‘s journey, though, is a path to wisdom (in Pullman’s understanding), and the series intimates and invites us to a number of beliefs, judgements, and questions about religion, authority, sexuality, and art. And though I fundamentally reject Pullman’s worldview, I resonate with Lyra’s journey–even as it goes in a direction that diverges from my own. I also critique the book, showing where I think Pullman succeeds and fails as a storyteller trying to intimate meaning. Frankly, I also use His Dark Materials as a test of my own heart: Looking honestly at myself as I read, could it be that I am really just using my own fears and beliefs to obscure a great work of literary art?
I don’t know if this spectrum is available to every book–though I think books shade to one side or another. The more I try to enrich my reading of Narnia by studying history, reading fairy tales, understanding Lewis’s life and culture, and writing my own prose and poetry, the more I find Narnia fits in the greenish pathways for me–some negotiation of text and reader. This is quite opposed to those who think Narnia is an “allegory” and decide that it is a singular vision. I gleefully misunderstood Animal Farm the first time I read it, showing that although an allegory fits in that orange-yellow part of the spectrum, I could successfully create remarkably consistent new (blue) meaning in my ignorance. I almost always read Richard Bach’s Jonathan Livingston Seagull completely in the blue spectrum, but I suspect I am self-deluded and am intimating something of the author’s orange-yellow-greenness.
My point here is not to limit reading, readers, or that which is read.
Rather, I think it is helpful to know what we are doing when we read. It is very easy to be reductive–to reduce Narnia to an allegory, to limit Pullman by his own anti-Narnian tendencies, to ignore our own biases, or to blame George Orwell for how wrong he was about the 2020s roll-out of AI in his futuristic novel, Animal Farm. This spectrum may or may not work for you, but I hope it helps us take a step out of fuzzy nonsense and obscure debates about literature so that we can enjoy the books we enjoy on whole new levels.
- Text Points to the Path: Text teaches directly, laying out the moral (ethical, political, theological, relational, or artistic) vision
- Text Symbolizes the Path: Text teaches indirectly, using symbol to reveal the moral vision (allegory, allegorical elements, symbols, mythic meaning)
- Text Invites to the Path: Text invites the reader to look where the text is looking, morally speaking, where the teaching is not direct or symbolical, but emerges from character, plot, atmosphere, or other literary quality
- Text and Reader Share the Path: A reader’s moral vision overlaps with some aspect of the text’s moral vision, questions, or literary quality, though the larger consequences or concerns might be different; thus, the text and reader can share some part of the journey toward the reader’s moral vision, but not all
- Reader’s Path Resonates With Text: A reader’s moral vision or questions find some sort of resonance with some aspect of the text, like character, plot, atmosphere, or other literary quality–though the reader and text are asking quite different questions and may not share a moral vision
- Reader’s Path Alternative to Text Path: A reader’s moral vision or questions is dramatically opposed to some aspect of the text–like the moral vision of the text itself, the questions it asks, the character, plot, atmosphere, or other literary quality–and the reader uses the text antipathetically to speak to the reader’s moral vision
- Reader’s Path Distinct from Text Path: A reader’s moral vision does not overlap with the text’s moral vision, the reader and text are asking different questions, and there isn’t anything in the text–like character, plot, atmosphere, or other literary quality–that resonates or opposes with the reader’s moral vision or questions, and yet the reader uses the text to speak to the reader’s moral vision or questions (but why use the text)
Greetings fellow pilgrims on the path of curiosity and imaginative adventure. Things have been quiet here on the blog front, but some great new things are happening in the background. One of these projects is a brand new short course with Signum University’s SPACE program. SPACE is an online, interactive, non-credit short course program. It is really quite a gorgeous program for folks who want to engage in great discussions and learn about things they love.
Last fall, I taught “ Reading L.M. Montgomery as Fantasy: Anne of Green Gables ,” and it was one of my favourite teaching experiences ever. In fact, there might be a chance to run the course again in November. If you are interested, you can “wish list” the course here. For details on SPACE, including the cost of courses ($100-$150 USD), click here .
This year, I am offering what I think is a unique approach both to C.S. Lewis and to creative writing as an art. “Ink Spots and Tea Stains: What We Learn from C.S. Lewis’s Writing Habits” is a confirmed October SPACE module. I have spent hundreds of hours in C.S. Lewis’s archives, working with original manuscripts and the various drafts in his writing process. I have studied his letters, diaries, and autobiographical materials to discern his process. And I have researched what we can know about Lewis as a prose writer and poet in all his modes, including experts like Walter Hooper (a literary secretary), Diana Pavlac Glyer (on creative collaboration and the Inklings), and Charlie Starr (who has developed a system of analyzing and dating Lewis’s handwritten manuscripts).
Without ignoring the lines themselves, what can we learn from C.S. Lewis about writing, imaginative expression, personal discipline, and literary subcreation when we look between, beside, and behind the lines.
The name for this course comes from my experience visiting the Berg Collection at the New York Public Library, and sitting with the manuscript of The Screwtape Letters . There were a number of ink spots–Lewis used writing technology that matched his creative process–and there was a prominent round stain from one of his mugs of tea on a neat, clean page. In that moment, I began to understand Lewis as an artist. I also realized that much of what has been said about Lewis the Writer needs some rethinking.
You can find out more about the course and how to register here . Let me know if you have any questions. http://blackberry.signumuniversity.org/r/n9xF0y
C.S. Lewis is one of the most prolific and influential writers of the 20th century. And yet, in his early career as an Oxford don, he viewed himself as a failed poet. Moreover, his most canonical and transformational writing happened during the most stress-filled periods of his life. This short course allows students to peek into the writing life of C.S. Lewis. Our goal is to see through the lines of printed text by visiting the letters and archival remains of Lewis in a virtual setting. Most of C.S. Lewis’s papers remain undigitized and unpublished, available only locally at archives in North America and England.
As Professor Brenton Dickieson has visited these archives , he is able to invite students to appreciate C.S. Lewis’s writing life by looking at the way that he consciously and unconsciously built his literary career. This course is for writers who are developing their own habits and literary life-prints, as well as folks who are curious about C.S. Lewis’s life beyond the biographies and bestselling books.
We are not doing text close readings, but looking at the “paratextual” information available to us: writing drafts, letters, diary entries, manuscripts and typescripts, titles, and the like.
Week 1: Lewis: Pen, Ink, Paper • C.S. Lewis’s Single-jointed Self-Conception as a Writer • What Lewis Says about his Writing Habits • Legendary Bonfires, Stuffed Dolls, and American Suckers: A Story of Lewis’s Papers and Manuscripts • The Screwtape MS. Story : Part 1
Week 2: Leaves, Bombs, Stains • The Screwtape MS. Story: Part 2 • “Villainous Handwriting”: Charlie Starr’s Lewis Handwriting and Rough Draft vs. Fair Draft • Reconsidering the Lindskoog Affair with Manuscript Evidence of “The Dark Tower”
Week 3: Joy, Theft, Death • “ The Quest of Bleheris ”: Lewis’s Teenage Novel
Week 4: Hits and Mythes • Is it True that Lewis Wrote in a Single Draft? • A Grief Observed • Tumbling Through the Wardrobe: The Discovery of Narnia • Arthurian Torso • A New Sketch of Lewis’s Writing Process(es)
Get Pilgrim Posts in Your Inbox
Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
Email Address
Start the Journey! Click Here!
- Search for:
Connect & Follow!
- View Brenton Dickieson’s profile on Facebook
- View @BrentonDana’s profile on Twitter
- View bdickieson’s profile on Instagram
- View brentondickieson’s profile on LinkedIn
Like us on Facebook
Recent Posts
- A Mailbox Note on Mark Noll’s C.S. Lewis in America (2023)
- Two Free Online Inklings Events Today: George MacDonald, Charles Williams, and J.R.R. Tolkien
- What Are Your Favourite Nonfiction Book Covers?
Most Popular Posts
- October 2024
- September 2024
- February 2024
- January 2024
- December 2023
- November 2023
- October 2023
- September 2023
- August 2023
- January 2023
- December 2022
- November 2022
- October 2022
- September 2022
- August 2022
- February 2022
- January 2022
- December 2021
- November 2021
- October 2021
- September 2021
- August 2021
- February 2021
- January 2021
- December 2020
- November 2020
- October 2020
- September 2020
- August 2020
- February 2020
- January 2020
- December 2019
- November 2019
- October 2019
- September 2019
- August 2019
- February 2019
- January 2019
- December 2018
- November 2018
- October 2018
- September 2018
- August 2018
- February 2018
- January 2018
- December 2017
- November 2017
- October 2017
- September 2017
- August 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016
- September 2016
- August 2016
- February 2016
- January 2016
- December 2015
- November 2015
- October 2015
- September 2015
- August 2015
- February 2015
- January 2015
- December 2014
- November 2014
- October 2014
- September 2014
- August 2014
- February 2014
- January 2014
- December 2013
- November 2013
- October 2013
- September 2013
- August 2013
- February 2013
- January 2013
- December 2012
- November 2012
- October 2012
- September 2012
- August 2012
- February 2012
- January 2012
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- Anne of Green Gables
- Charles Williams
- children's literature
- Collected Letters of C.S. Lewis
- Dorothy L. Sayers
- film adaptation
- George MacDonald
- Harry Potter
- J.K. Rowling
- J.R.R. Tolkien
- Joy Davidman
- L.M. Montgomery
- lion the witch and the wardrobe
- Lord of the Rings
- Lucy Maud Montgomery
- Madeleine L'Engle
- owen barfield
- Peter Jackson
- Prince Edward Island
- Ransom Trilogy
- Science Fiction
- Signum University
- Stephen King
- Surprised by Joy
- That Hideous Strength
- The Great Divorce
- Theology of Culture
- The Screwtape Letters
- Walter Hooper
- Entries feed
- Comments feed
- WordPress.org
- 10 Minute Book Talk
- 5 Books Series
- Blogging the Hugos
- Canadian literature
- Creative Writing
- Feature Friday
- Fictional Worlds
- Guest Blogs
- Inklings and Arthur
- Lewis Biography
- Lewis' Essays
- Memorable Quotes
- News & Links
- Original Research
- Reflections
- Studies in Words
- The C.S. Lewis Studies Series
- The MaudCast
- Thoughtful Essays
- Throwback Thursdays
- 2,051,467 visitors to A Pilgrim in Narnia
A Pilgrim in 140 Charcters
Connect on instagram.
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
Listed below are some of the best biographies and guides that help us better understand C.S. Lewis. We’ve included excerpts from the books where available via Google Books. *** The Best C.S. Lewis Biography … 1) Jack: A Life of C. S. Lewis by George Sayer
Clive Staples Lewis FBA (29 November 1898 – 22 November 1963) was a British writer, literary scholar, and Anglican lay theologian. He held academic positions in English literature at both Magdalen College, Oxford (1925–1954), and Magdalene College, Cambridge (1954–1963). He is best known as the author of The Chronicles of Narnia, but he is also noted for his other works of fiction, su…
C.S. Lewis was a prolific Irish writer and scholar best known for his 'Chronicles of Narnia' fantasy series and his pro-Christian texts.
'A Brief Guide to C.S. Lewis: The Man Who Created Narnia' by Paul Simpson (2012) 'C.S. Lewis: A Life: Eccentric Genius, Reluctant Prophet' by Alister E. McGrath (2012) 'A Life Observed: A …
Here, I talk about 5 biographies of C.S. Lewis, each with a different way of looking at his story. The conversation includes: #1 A personal biography by student and friend, George Sayer, Jack: A Life of C.S. Lewis #2 …
He is widely regarded as one of the most influential authors of the 20th century. In honor of his life, here’s a list of 10 of his best works. What the last day of C.S. Lewis’s life was like, 60 years ago today. 1.