business negotiation case study pdf

• Browse Topics
• Executive Committee
• Affiliated Faculty
• Harvard Negotiation Project
• Great Negotiator
• American Secretaries of State Project
• Awards, Grants, and Fellowships
• Negotiation Programs
• Mediation Programs
• One-Day Programs
• In-House Training – Inquiry Form
• In-Person Programs
• Online Programs
• Advanced Materials Search
• Contact Information
• The Teaching Negotiation Resource Center Policies
• Frequently Asked Questions
• Negotiation Journal
• Harvard Negotiation Law Review
• Working Conference on AI, Technology, and Negotiation
• 40th Anniversary Symposium
• Free Reports and Program Guides

Free Videos

• Upcoming Events
• Past Events
• Event Series
• Our Mission
• Keyword Index

PON – Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School - https://www.pon.harvard.edu

Team-Building Strategies: Building a Winning Team for Your Organization

Discover how to build a winning team and boost your business negotiation results in this free special report, Team Building Strategies for Your Organization, from Harvard Law School.

A Top International Negotiation Case Study in Business: The Microsoft-Nokia Deal

International negotiation topics in business: merging two distinct corporate cultures with as little conflict as possible.

By PON Staff — on May 2nd, 2024 / International Negotiation

We sometimes require counterparts to meet certain conditions before agreeing to enter into talks. Negotiating conditions to your participation in dealmaking can be a powerful move, but it also carries some risks that need to be carefully considered. And international negotiation brings on more challenges than most. 

Let’s look at the international negotiation case study of Microsoft’s decision to purchase Finnish mobile phone company Nokia’s mobile device business for $9.5 billion. The deal, which closed in 2014, quickly proved disastrous: Microsoft wrote off nearly all of the deal’s value and laid off thousands of workers in July 2015. Although there were many reasons the deal was a bad bet for Microsoft, a negotiating condition that Nokia set before agreeing to take part in serious negotiations may have offered one warning sign. 

Claim your FREE copy: International Negotiations

Claim your copy of International Negotiations: Cross-Cultural Communication Skills for International Business Executives from
 the Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School.

International Negotiation Behind the Microsoft and Nokia Deal: Nokia Builds Its BATNA

Microsoft and Nokia had been partners since 2011, when the Finnish firm began installing Microsoft’s Windows Phone operating system (OS) on its smartphones. But Nokia lagged far behind smartphone competitors in innovation and market share, and the Windows Phone OS, used primarily on Nokia handsets, was failing to meet expectations.

In January 2013, Microsoft CEO Steven Ballmer called Risto Siilasmaa, the chairman of Nokia’s board of directors, to raise the possibility of Microsoft buying divisions of Nokia. Soon after, the two men discussed the idea at a conference in Spain. They agreed inefficiencies existed in their agreement and brainstormed solutions, from minor tweaks to business mergers, reports Ina Fried on the technology news website AllThingsD.com . 

Nokia considered letting its deal with Microsoft lapse and trying to revive its handset business by adapting its smartphones to Google’s Android system. By cultivating this strong BATNA , or best alternative to a negotiated agreement, Nokia gained the power to walk away from a subpar offer from Microsoft.

Indeed, after hearing Microsoft’s first formal pitch for an acquisition in New York, Siilasmaa informed Ballmer that they were too far apart on price and other issues, such as which company would own Here, Nokia’s mapping service. Nokia executives believed they needed to hold on to their ability to sell Here to other companies. Meanwhile, Microsoft felt it couldn’t keep pace with competitors without controlling the mapping technology it was using in its phones, tablets, and PCs, and on the web, according to AllThingsD.com. Subsequent meetings between the parties in London and Finland went nowhere .  

A Deal Takes Shape

A breakthrough came when Nokia informed Microsoft that it would proceed with formal talks only if Microsoft agreed to abide by certain negotiating conditions , most notably a commitment to set up a financing source for Nokia and the caveat that Here was off the table. 

Microsoft agreed. At a meeting in New York, the parties happened upon a solution to the question of who would control the mapping service. Why not share the code, with Nokia retaining intellectual-property rights to Here? Nokia realized it could grant Microsoft a license to access and customize Here’s source code and own any improvements it made. Nokia would retain ownership of Here and the power to license the service to other companies. Ballmer and Siilasmaa shook hands on the outlines of an agreement, which was filled out over the next two months. 

The Risks of Setting Negotiating Conditions

A negotiating condition is an “if” statement—such as, “If you agree to take this issue off the table, I’ll negotiate”—that qualifies your entry into a negotiation or acceptance of a deal. Setting negotiating conditions can be a particularly useful tool when it comes to improving the appeal of another party’s onerous request or demand, notes Harvard Business School and Harvard Law School professor Guhan Subramanian

But insisting that the other party agree to certain terms as a precondition to negotiation can be risky. In their 2012 labor dispute, for example, the musicians of the Minnesota Orchestra said for many months that they would negotiate with the orchestra’s management only after a lockout ended. But management was loath to accept this negotiating condition , aware that the players would have little motivation to accept significant salary cuts if they were performing and being paid. 

Before stipulating a negotiating condition , remember that your counterpart will weigh the costs and benefits of accepting your negotiating conditions against their alternatives away from the table. If you have a strong BATNA , as Nokia appeared to, then it may make sense to take this risk. But note that even in this case, Microsoft made inroads on the mapping service issue that Nokia had claimed was nonnegotiable. Microsoft may have salvaged the deal by refusing to assume that Nokia’s negotiating conditions were nonnegotiable—a move Microsoft’s leaders likely later came to regret.

Two key lessons on negotiating terms and conditions emerge from these failed negotiation examples . First, you should demand only those conditions that are truly deal breakers for you. Second, try to craft negotiating conditions in ways that provide benefits or concessions to your counterpart. Even when you have the power to get what you want, your efforts to help your counterparts get what they want will pay off in the form of stronger relationships and longer-lasting deals.

Have you had experience negotiating conditions to a deal within an international negotiation? If so, how did the process work out?

Related Posts

• Political Negotiation: Negotiating with Bureaucrats
• International Arbitration: What it is and How it Works
• Diplomatic Negotiations: The Surprising Benefits of Conflict and Teamwork at the Negotiation Table
• The Importance of Relationship Building in China
• Overcoming Cultural Barriers in Negotiations and the Importance of Communication in International Business Deals

No Responses to “A Top International Negotiation Case Study in Business: The Microsoft-Nokia Deal”

3 responses to “a top international negotiation case study in business: the microsoft-nokia deal”.

There are no more phones with ‘Nokia Lumia’. They are all ‘Microsoft Lumia’. Microsoft completely scraped the company and rebranded the devices. Nokia got a bad future

There has been a completely mixed response to whether the deal was good or was a decision taken in a hurry. Nokia surely can use this incoming cash flow on some great products, but the issue now is that Nokia was recognized by its Mobile Devices and there will be almost zero difference between a new product category (coz no more mobile phones)coming under the NOKIA brand name or a completely new Brand name because they will both have zero popularity in that field.

It would probably be good for Nokia to come up with a new brand name and leave the Nokia legacy behind in its Nokia Research Department and nowhere else. As you could feel, this deal saddens me 🙁

It’s 2015 now buddy and Nokia’s all of microsoft now. You should be a lot sad now 😛

Click here to cancel reply.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Negotiation and Leadership

• Download Program Guide: Fall 2024 Spring 2025
• Register Online: Fall 2024 Spring 2025
• Learn More about Negotiation and Leadership

NEGOTIATION MASTER CLASS

• Download Program Guide: November 2024
• Register Online: November 2024
• Learn More about Harvard Negotiation Master Class

Negotiation Essentials Online

• Download Program Guide: December 2024 and June 2025
• Register Online: December 2024 June 2025
• Learn More about Negotiation Essentials Online

Beyond the Back Table: Working with People and Organizations to Get to Yes

• Download Program Guide: February 2025
• Register Online: February 2025
• Learn More about Beyond the Back Table

Select Your Free Special Report

• Negotiation and Leadership Spring 2025 Program Guide
• Negotiation Essentials Online (NEO) December 2024 and June 2025 Program Guide
• Negotiation Essentials In-House Program Guide
• Negotiation Master Class November 2024 Program Guide
• Beyond the Back Table February 2025 Program Guide
• Negotiation and Leadership Fall 2024 Program Guide
• Make the Most of Online Negotiations
• Managing Multiparty Negotiations
• Getting the Deal Done
• Salary Negotiation: How to Negotiate Salary: Learn the Best Techniques to Help You Manage the Most Difficult Salary Negotiations and What You Need to Know When Asking for a Raise

Teaching Negotiation Resource Center

• Teaching Materials and Publications

Stay Connected to PON

Preparing for negotiation.

Understanding how to arrange the meeting space is a key aspect of preparing for negotiation. In this video, Professor Guhan Subramanian discusses a real world example of how seating arrangements can influence a negotiator’s success. This discussion was held at the 3 day executive education workshop for senior executives at the Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School.

Guhan Subramanian is the Professor of Law and Business at the Harvard Law School and Professor of Business Law at the Harvard Business School.

Articles & Insights

• BATNAs: Beyond the Basics
• The Good Cop, Bad Cop Negotiation Strategy
• Michael Scott, Negotiation Genius? Lessons from TV Negotiations
• BATNA and Other Sources of Power at the Negotiation Table
• BATNA Strategy: Should You Reveal Your BATNA?
• The Importance of Negotiation in Business and Your Career
• In the Negotiation Planning Process, to Capture the Force, be Patient
• Negotiation Advice for Buying a Car: Tips for Improving Your Negotiating Position
• 10 Great Examples of Negotiation in Business
• Top 10 Notable Negotiations of 2022
• Case Study of Conflict Management: To Resolve Disputes and Manage Conflicts, Assume a Neutral 3rd Party Role
• Pros and Cons of Email Communication
• 3 Types of Conflict and How to Address Them
• What is Conflict Resolution, and How Does It Work?
• How to Manage Conflict at Work
• Crisis Negotiation Lessons: The U.S.-Russia Prisoner Swap
• What is Crisis Management in Negotiation?
• Famous Negotiations Cases – NBA and the Power of Deadlines at the Bargaining Table
• Crisis Communication Examples: What’s So Funny?
• AI Negotiation in the News
• Dealing with Difficult People: Coping with an Insulting Offer in Contract Negotiations
• Trust and Honesty in Negotiations: Dealing with Dishonest Negotiators
• Bargaining in Bad Faith: Dealing with “False Negotiators”
• How to Renegotiate a Bad Deal
• Consensus-Building Techniques
• How Does Mediation Work in a Lawsuit?
• 7 Tips for Closing the Deal in Negotiations
• MESO Negotiation: The Benefits of Making Multiple Equivalent Simultaneous Offers in Business Negotiations
• What Leads to Renegotiation?
• Does Your Negotiation Process Need Improvement?
• Cultural Barriers and Conflict Negotiation Strategies: Apple’s Apology in China
• What is Dispute System Design?
• Settling Out of Court: Negotiating in the Shadow of the Law
• What are the Three Basic Types of Dispute Resolution? What to Know About Mediation, Arbitration, and Litigation
• Four Conflict Negotiation Strategies for Resolving Value-Based Disputes
• How Collaborative Leadership Helped Former Competitors Profit
• Directive Leadership: When It Does—and Doesn’t—Work
• Counteracting Negotiation Biases Like Race and Gender in the Workplace
• What Is Collective Leadership?
• The Trait Theory of Leadership
• Why is Negotiation Important: Mediation in Transactional Negotiations
• How Mediation Can Help Resolve Pro Sports Disputes
• The Mediation Process and Dispute Resolution
• What Makes a Good Mediator?
• AI Mediation: Using AI to Help Mediate Disputes
• Top 10 Negotiation Skills You Must Learn to Succeed
• Chatbot Negotiations: What Can AI Do for You?
• Identify Your Negotiation Style: Advanced Negotiation Strategies and Concepts
• The Benefits of Coalitions at the Bargaining Table
• Dear Negotiation Coach: Dealing with an Exploding Offer
• 10 Negotiation Training Skills Every Organization Needs
• 3-D Negotiation Strategy
• Use a Negotiation Preparation Worksheet for Continuous Improvement
• The Importance of a Relationship in Negotiation
• Collaborative Negotiation Examples: Tenants and Landlords
• How to Ask for a Salary Increase
• Negotiating a Salary When Compensation Is Public
• Salary Negotiation: How to Ask for a Higher Salary
• How to Counter a Job Offer: Avoid Common Mistakes
• Renegotiate Salary to Your Advantage
• Negotiation Journal Now Open Access, New Issue Just Released!
• Teaching the Fundamentals: The Best Introductory Negotiation Role Play Simulations
• Teach Your Students to Negotiate a Management Crisis
• Learn from the Best with the Great Negotiator Case Studies
• The Best New Simulations
• For NFL Players, a Win-Win Negotiation Contract Only in Retrospect?
• Streaming Toward Win-Win Negotiation: Spotify Upgrades Its Negotiating Strategy
• What is a Win-Win Negotiation?
• How to Negotiate Mutually Beneficial Noncompete Agreements
• Labor Negotiation Strategies

PON Publications

• Negotiation Data Repository (NDR)
• New Frontiers, New Roleplays: Next Generation Teaching and Training
• Negotiating Transboundary Water Agreements
• Learning from Practice to Teach for Practice—Reflections From a Novel Training Series for International Climate Negotiators
• Insights From PON’s Great Negotiators and the American Secretaries of State Program
• Gender and Privilege in Negotiation

Remember Me This setting should only be used on your home or work computer.

Lost your password? Create a new password of your choice.

Copyright © 2024 Negotiation Daily. All rights reserved.

• About our Courses
• Sales Negotiation Training
• Procurement Negotiation Training
• Essential Negotiator
• Project Management
• Negotiation Simulation Game
• Advanced Negotiation Training
• Customized Negotiation Training
• Open Enrolment Calendar
• Course Comparison
• eTournament

Home » Case Studies

Case Studies

Researchers and students asked us for case studies, so we delivered. We hope that you're able to learn from these practical examples from around the world. Check out our negotiation training when you're ready to elevate your negotiation capability.

Issues in Negotiation: How to Solve a Problem

Negotiating with WalMart Buyers

How Microsoft Outnegotiated Netscape in the Browser War

Trust Building in a Trilateral China Japan Western Negotiation

Nepal–India Water Negotiations (Power Asymmetry)

Business Expansion Woven From Trust

Camp David Third Party Intervener

The Cost of Death on Chinese Roads

The Panama Canal Negotiations

Contract Renegotiation with the Chilean Government

A Negotiation Case Study: Exploring the Enron Case in India

Scientists and Bureaucrats - Orientation Issues

Gaming in Shanghai

Andorra Versus the European Community (EC)

How Giving Face in China Translates to Negotiation Success

Creative Problem-Solving in Negotiations

Power in Negotiation

Kuwait Invasion Negotiation Perspective

Lehman Leadership Negotiation Rivalry

Chinese Water Selling Negotiation

Newsletter Signup