14 parents (9 fathers/5 mothers)
35–53 years
13 adolescents (9 girls/4 boys)
12–18 years
Qualitative study (1) To examine mediation strategies defined by previous studies and their relevance for the use of social media. (2) To explore the relation between social media literacy of the parents and the choice of a certain mediation strategy. | The definition of the concept proposed by Vanwynsberghe et al., (2015) is used. These authors state they are technical and cognitive competences that users must develop so social interactions and communication on the Internet are effective and efficient. | 1. Technical competences: related to the knowledge and skills to create, review, organize, produce, and share content on social media. 2. Critical cognitive competences: refer to the analysis and assessment of information and context in which it takes place considering its relevance and reliability. | 2. Festl (2020) [ ] | Germany 1508 students 11–18 years 66% women | Quantitative study To propose the construct of social media literacy based on skills and to develop a standardized instrument. | The concept proposed by Festl (2020) is based on the relevance that social media have to satisfy human needs such as feeling and being connected to others, especially for teenagers. This definition is based on the proposal by Pfaff-Rüdinger and Riesmeyeer (2016). | - Social competences consist of: 1. Participatory/moral competences: those related to participation without damaging others and being honest. 2. Communicative competences: refer, for example, to teenagers talking with their friends about experiences on the Internet. 3. Educational competences: related to showing others how Internet applications are used. - Each of the competences are assessed with a process-oriented perspective, i.e., considering knowledge, skills, motivation, and behavior (performance). |
3. Gordon et al., (2020) [ ] | Australia 700 students 11–15 years 50% men | Quantitative study To evaluate the effectiveness of a school social media literacy intervention for early adolescents. | This concept is based on media literacy, favoring understanding over how the information on social media is presented, e.g., publications by people vs. commercial enterprises. In addition, it addresses the motivations on which the selection and the way in which contents are shown are based. This is to protect against the negative impact of social media use on body image. The possibility of creating content is considered. | 1. Critical thinking against the publicity on social media. Favoring the evaluation of the realism on social media to reduce the persuasion of these digital platforms. 2. Socio-emotional skills for interaction on social media. 3. Skills that make it possible to create content on social media that is positive and realistic. |
4. Livingstone (2014) [ ] | United Kingdom, Spain, Czech Republic. 48 participants 9–16 years | Qualitative study To introduce the concept of social media literacy. To explore the opportunities and risks that children experience on theInternet. | This concept addresses the tasks of decoding, evaluating, creating, communicating in different ways (text, image, platform, device, etc.), as well as social interaction (relations, privacy, anonymity, etc.), since these skills are integrated into the use of social media. This concept is based on media literacy and responds to the present needs of children and to the possibilities of connecting to social media, considering the positive (online opportunities) and negative consequences (risk of damage online). | |
5. Livingstone (2015) [ ] | United Kingdom | Theoretical study To understand the transformation of mass media and their differences with social media. | Social media literacy is understood as the update of media literacy to perform more suitable analyses of such digital platforms, since they are at the interface between “social” and “media”, which will enrich, expand, and update the important tradition of mass media education. | |
6. McLean et al., (2017) [ ] | Australia 101 teenage girls 13.13 years | Quantitative study To examine the effectiveness of an intervention in social media literacy on risk factors related to eating disorders in adolescents. | It is understood as integration of the media literacy and peer group theory resulting in an effective proposal for prevention. | The relevance of critical thinking in response to social media content is highlighted. |
7. Newman (2015) [ ] | United States | Theoretical study To address the effects of the use of Instagram on the development of identity in young adults. To propose three skills needed for social media literacy. | | 1. To understand the functions of Instagram: knowledge and understanding of the application and its emphasis on the artistic and visual expression of the content. 2. To evaluate and understand the authenticity of communication based on images considering the social comparison that takes place based on publications or content affecting the construction of social identity. 3. Genuine belonging: understanding that the positive feedback of other users is not necessarily related to belonging to a group. |
8. Pangrazio and Cardozo-Gaibisso (2020) [ ] | Australia Uruguay 276 preadolescents from 7 to 12 years | Quantitative study To identify digital practices, challenges, and consequences in preadolescents. | | 1. To represent digital identities in every context: to understand how the functioning of social media has implications for identity development. In addition, how digital platforms through the digital fingerprint and shared information are used to make inferences on a person’s identity. 2. To understand the implications of generating personal data: to understand that digital platforms have the power to use and distribute their users’ data with other digital companies or platforms. 3. To manage and protect the privacy in media contexts: involves understanding what content to share and with whom. Privacy management depends on the digital platform. |
9. Schreurs and Vandenbosch (2020) [ ] | Belgium | Theoretical study | Inasmuch as people who use social media have cognitive and affective structures that can guarantee the reduction of the risks in interactions with social media content, while they increase the benefits at the same time. | 1. Cognitive structures: envisage (a) traditional media literacy; (b) characteristics of mass media; (c) dynamics of interpersonal communication on social media. 2. Affective structures: oriented to the ability to apply adaptive strategies in that than they are maladaptive when negative experiences are suffered |
10. Syam and Nurrahmi (2020) [ ] | Indonesia 500 students 17–24 years 46% men | Mixed method study To propose a framework of media literacy to study the critical ability of university students to process fake news on social media. | | 1. Competences to access social media content: to find information and use the functions. It is also relevant to understand the meaning of this content that encompasses understanding publications and the use of emoticons. 2. Competences to interpret the textual meaning of social media content: involves the ability to synthesize and critically assess the information from different social media. In the case of fake news, it offers the possibility of evaluating the credibility of the information on social media. 3. Competences to operate software: they can create, distribute, and duplicate multimedia content, i.e., gives account of the ability to create social media accounts, publish images or photos, skills to make videos and memes. 4. Competences to interpret social media content considering its context: envisages active and critical participation with regard to the information presented on social media. |
11. Tamplin et al., (2018) [ ] | Australia 374 participants 50% women 18–30 years | Quantitative study (1) To examine the impact of exposure to images of idealized appearance on social media on the body image of young women and men. (2) To examine social media literacy and its protective role against the negative effect of the exposure to images of idealized appearance on social media. (3) To examine whether the evaluated risk factors at the beginning of the study would moderate the effects of exposure to social media images on body satisfaction. | Understood as the knowledge and development of skills to analyze, evaluate, produce, and participate in social media, which favors critical thinking. This definition is supported by McLean, Wertheim, Masters, and Paxton (2017). Specifically, the ability to understand the motivations and techniques of companies that produce and publish commercial images and advertising, such as publications from friends and celebrity, in which the modification of images and the publication of images with a positivity bias are present. | Development of critical thinking based on the ability to assess the intent, meaning, and realism of the images and content in general on social media. |
12. Tandoc et al., (2021) [ ] | Singapore 3154 participants Qualitative study 62 participants 18–66 years Quantitative study 1021 participants 34.98 years (SD = 11.26) 50% women. 1000 participants 40.83 year (SD = 15.07) 52% women 1071 participants 40.39 year (SD = 12.26) 50% men | Mixed method study To examine which competences social media users require to avoid problems on social media. | | 1. Technical competences: involves knowing how to create or delete an account, how to add friends and how to publish information. 2. Privacy and algorithmic awareness: need to protect personal information or content posted on social media platforms, for which it would be relevant to know the privacy settings and limit what it is published. It also involves awareness about how private data are used to modify the experience on social media. Thus, critical thinking competences are necessary. 3. Management of social relations: linked to the management strategies of interpersonal communication. They may also be associated with technical competences, for example, when the friends’ network has to be segmented so certain publications are hidden from some people. 4. Informational awareness: refers to the competences to distinguish between information and accounts that can be true or false. |
13. Vanwynsberghe and Verdegem (2013) [ ] | Belgium | Theoretical study To propose a multidimensional framework to integrate social media literacy in an education environment. | It is understood as the practical, cognitive, and affective competences required to access, analyze, evaluate, and create content on social media in a variety of contexts. In addition, the understanding of the implications of the participatory culture on social media is contemplated, which considers: (1) using and applying media literacy in the participatory culture generated on social media; (2) visualizing and contemplating the differences among the different social media; (3) being aware of the change from passive consumption to users who are active in content creation. | Conceptual proposal that consists of three competences and sub-competences: 1. Cognitive competences: considers the knowledge and critical thinking to analyze and evaluate social media. 2. Practical competences: includes the possibility of creating content on social media, also involves looking for, opening, and reading information on social media. 3. Affective competences: considers motivational disposition and self-efficacy. It also alludes to the possibilities of communicating adequately with other people through social media. In addition: 4. The interaction between the consequences related to these three activities, including the understanding of the dissemination of personal information and the commodification present on social media. |
14. Vanwynsberghe et al. (2015) [ ] | Belgium 184 librarians 73.5% women. 24 to 63 years (46.28 years; SD = 9.75) | Quantitative study To identify the profiles of librarians in relation to social media literacy. | The definition by Vanwynsberghe and Verdegem, 2013 is used, considering the development of competences and the motivation to interact and communicate effectively and appropriately. | 1. Cognitive competences: alludes to the critical analysis and evaluation of motives and objectives behind the consumed contents, the language of the messages, and the context in which the content is produced. 2. Affective competences: refers to the motivation and attitude to social media manifested in the assessment of social media and the behavior displayed. 3. Practical competences: envisage access and knowledge about how social media work. The authors refer to these competences as “knowledge of the buttons”. |
15. Yeh and Swinehart (2020) [ ] | United States 66 students 51.5% women. 18–21 years | Mixed method study To examine the characteristics and trends of social media use by students of English. | This study uses the definition by Vanwynsberghe et al. (2015) in relation to social media literacy. | 1. Technical competences: it includes how to access, create, navigate, organize, and share content on social media considering the distribution and design specific to each platform. 2. Cognitive competences: refer to understanding, evaluating, and critically analyzing social media content considering its context, application, and credibility. It also includes the information overload that leads to difficulties in evaluating it, particularly considering anonymity. 3. Sociocultural pragmatics of online environments: This refers to the change that occurs in the language, interaction, and behavior as part of different social and cultural contexts formed online. Specifically, in this study the informal use of the language is considered relevant. |
Funding Statement
K.P.-L. received financial support by the National Agency for Research and Development (ANID)/Scholarship Program/DOCTORADO BECAS CHILE/2020-21200712.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, K.P.-L. and S.S.-G.; methodology, K.P.-L. and S.S.-G.; formal analysis, K.P.-L. and S.S.-G.; investigation, K.P.-L. and S.S.-G.; data curation, K.P.-L. and S.S.-G.; writing—original draft preparation, K.P.-L. and S.S.-G.; writing—review and editing, K.P.-L. and S.S.-G.; supervision, K.P.-L. and S.S.-G.; All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Institutional Review Board Statement
Informed consent statement, data availability statement, conflicts of interest.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
2. Writing a Literature Review
Objective: To help draft a literature review on the effects of social media on academic performance.
Prompt Example:
Summarise key findings from recent studies (post-2018) on the topic.
Compare and contrast different methodologies used in these studies.
Highlight gaps in the current research that could be explored further.
Ensure the review is structured with an introduction, main body, and conclusion.
Use formal academic language and cite sources in Harvard referencing style.
Audience: Second-year undergraduate students in psychology.
Expected Outcome: A draft literature review of approximately 500 words with a synthesis of recent research findings, a critical comparison of methodologies, and identification of research gaps, all presented in a coherent and scholarly manner.
Example User Query:
Draft a 500-word literature review on the effects of social media on academic performance. The review should cover the following points:
Summarise recent studies from 2018 onwards on this topic.
Compare and contrast the methodologies used in these studies.
Identify and discuss gaps in the current research that could be further explored.
Please structure the review with an introduction, main body, and conclusion, using formal academic language. Make sure to cite the sources using Harvard referencing style.
The target audience for this review is second-year undergraduate students in psychology.
ELM’s Response:
Introduction
The ubiquity of social media in contemporary society has sparked a growing body of research examining its effects on various aspects of life, including academic performance. This literature review aims to synthesise findings from recent studies (2018-present) on the impact of social media usage on academic performance. By comparing methodologies and identifying research gaps, this review seeks to provide a holistic understanding of the current academic discourse on this topic.
Summarising Recent Studies
Several recent studies have explored the connection between social media use and academic performance with varied findings. Wang and Xing (2018) conducted a survey-based study with university students in China, revealing a negative correlation between time spent on social media and academic grades. Similarly, a study by Kirschner and Karpinski (2020) in the United States found that students who used social media excessively had lower GPAs compared to their peers who used it less frequently.
Conversely, some studies report more nuanced outcomes. A longitudinal study by Al-Menayes (2019) found that while overall social media use did correlate with lower academic performance, this effect was moderated by the type of social media engagement — with academic-related use proving beneficial. Similarly, Cho et al. (2021) highlighted that the impact of social media on academic performance is not straightforward but contingent on factors such as the nature of use (active vs. passive) and individual differences in self-regulation.
Comparing and Contrasting Methodologies
The methodologies employed in these studies vary significantly, influencing the robustness and generalisability of their findings. Cross-sectional surveys, as used by Wang and Xing (2018) and Kirschner and Karpinski (2020), provide quick snapshots but are limited by their inability to infer causality. These studies typically rely on self-reported data, which may be subject to biases such as social desirability or inaccurate recall.
In contrast, longitudinal studies like that of Al-Menayes (2019) offer stronger evidence for causal relationships by tracking changes over time. However, they require more resources and time, and their findings can be influenced by external variables that change during the study period. Experimental designs, though less common in this field, could provide more definitive insights by controlling for extraneous variables, as suggested by Nowak and Gao (2022), who implemented a controlled experiment to isolate the effects of social media on academic tasks.
Identifying Research Gaps
Despite the valuable insights provided by recent research, several gaps remain. Firstly, there is a need for more experimental studies to establish causality more definitively and eliminate confounding variables. Additionally, much of the existing research focuses on Western or East Asian contexts, with limited exploration in other cultural settings. This geographical bias suggests a need for cross-cultural studies to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the phenomenon.
Furthermore, while some studies have begun to distinguish between different types of social media use, there remains a lack of granular investigation into the distinct effects of specific platforms. Kim and Venditti (2023) suggest that the varying functionalities and user interactions on platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and LinkedIn might differentially impact academic performance.
Conclusion
The existing literature offers valuable insights into the relationship between social media usage and academic performance, revealing both negative and context-dependent effects. Nevertheless, the methodological diversity and geographical concentration of studies highlight the need for further research, particularly experimental and cross-cultural inquiries, as well as platform-specific analyses. Addressing these gaps will enrich the understanding of how social media impacts academic outcomes and guide the development of effective educational strategies and policies.
References
Al-Menayes, J. J. (2019). ‘The relationship between social media use and academic performance in university students’ Global Media Journal, 17(33), pp. 1-11.
Cho, J., Kim, S., Lee, W. & Kim, S. (2021). ‘The moderating effect of self-control on the relationship between social media use and academic performance’ Computers in Human Behaviour, 123, p. 106873.
Kim, H. & Venditti, D. (2023). ‘Differentiated impacts of social media platforms on academic performance: An exploratory study’ Journal of Educational Technology, 45(2), pp. 200-214.
Kirschner, P. A., & Karpinski, A. C. (2020). ‘Facebook and academic performance’ Computers in Human Behavior, 26(6), pp. 1237-1245.
Nowak, G., & Gao, L. (2022). ‘Experimental study on social media and student learning outcomes’ Journal of Experimental Education, 90(3), pp. 512-529.
Wang, Q. & Xing, Q. (2018). ‘The impact of social media on academic performance: Evidence from Chinese university students’ International Journal of Educational Research, 95, pp. 1-9.
IEEE Account
- Change Username/Password
- Update Address
Purchase Details
- Payment Options
- Order History
- View Purchased Documents
Profile Information
- Communications Preferences
- Profession and Education
- Technical Interests
- US & Canada: +1 800 678 4333
- Worldwide: +1 732 981 0060
- Contact & Support
- About IEEE Xplore
- Accessibility
- Terms of Use
- Nondiscrimination Policy
- Privacy & Opting Out of Cookies
A not-for-profit organization, IEEE is the world's largest technical professional organization dedicated to advancing technology for the benefit of humanity. © Copyright 2024 IEEE - All rights reserved. Use of this web site signifies your agreement to the terms and conditions.
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
Abstract. Social media has become an integral part of contemporary society, profoundly transforming communication, social behavior, political engagement, and cultural norms. This paper presents a ...
This article focuses on studying the social media influence on an individual through systematic literature review (Brereton et al., 2007) with respect to TCCM approach (Theory, Context, Characteristics and Methodology). Adopting a framework or lens in literature reviews help in bringing objectivity to the analysis.
Introduction. The term "social media" (SM) was first used in 1994 on a Tokyo online media environment, called Matisse. 1 It was in these early days of the commercial Internet that the first SM platforms were developed and launched. Over time, both the number of SM platforms and the number of active SM users have increased significantly, making it one of the most important applications of ...
This section discusses the findings of this literature research. The findings are organized based on the key perspectives of the study. 3.1 Student Perspectives. Majority of the studies reviewed are focused on students' perspectives of the social media use for instructional purpose, using various social media tools, such as Facebook, Blog, Wiki, and in-house social network tools, etc ...
Social media use for knowledge sharing is comprised of interactive digital tools, allowing users to not only share knowledge, but also to create or influence content. ... This systematic literature review has revealed that the second-most used theory in social media for knowledge sharing research, is the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM).
Abstract. This manuscript explores the profound impact of social media on society, with a focus on social behavior, politics, and cultural norms. Employing a systematic literature review ...
In this article, we review existing research on the complementarity of social media data and survey data for the study of public opinion. We start by situating our review in the extensive literature (N = 187) about the uses, challenges, and frameworks related to the use of social media for studying public opinion.
The relevant literature on social media is reviewed to yield a better understanding of how it has transformed the way people communicate, acquire and use information. The development and expansion of social media have rapidly changed the interaction and communication of people, thereby attract- ing attention in an unprecedented scale. This paper reviews the relevant literature on social media ...
Although studies of social media use in the classroom potentially show the affordances of their incorporation, further research needs to be done on students' literacy and learning practices while using social media in schools (Stornaiuolo et al., 2013), especially those that forefront the use of photos and videos over traditional print text ...
Drawing on the critical literacy and affordances-in-practice frameworks, we explore the concept of critical social media literacy (CSML) through a systematic literature review to determine whether and how its components—users' goals, use context, inquiry, reflection, and action—have been addressed in the literature.
Kaplan and Haenlein (2010) de ne social media as "a group of Internet-based. applications that build on the ideological and technological foundations of Web. 2.0, and that allow the creation and ...
Literature reviews on how social media use affects adolescent mental health have accumulated at an unprecedented rate of late. Yet, a higher-level integration of the evidence is still lacking. We fill this gap with an up-to-date umbrella review, a review of reviews published between 2019 and mid-2021. Our search yielded 25 reviews: seven meta ...
The use of social media in higher education has been demonstrated in a number of studies to be an attractive and contemporary method of teaching and learning. However, further research and investigation are required in order to align social media's pedagogical benefits with the theoretical perspectives that inform educational practices. It is the objective of this study to provide a systematic ...
Schmeichel, Mardi; Hughes, Hilary E.; and Kutner, Mel (2018) "Qualitative Research on Youths' Social Media Use: A review of the literature," Middle Grades Review: Vol. 4 : Iss. 2 , Article 4. This Research is brought to you for free and open access by the College of Education and Social Services at ScholarWorks @ UVM.
Abstract. Social media are responsible for aggravating mental health problems. This systematic study summarizes the effects of social network usage on mental health. Fifty papers were shortlisted from google scholar databases, and after the application of various inclusion and exclusion criteria, 16 papers were chosen and all papers were ...
For optimal use of social media and digital platforms, marketing researchers and publishers might consider allying with communication experts, social media managers, and digital marketing professionals. ... J., Lim, W. M., O'Cass, A., Hao, A. W., & Bresciani, S. (2021). Scientific procedures and rationales for systematic literature reviews ...
Objective: This review aims to shed light on SM use worldwide and to discuss how it has been used as an essential tool in the health care industry from the perspective of HCPs. Methods: A literature review was conducted between March and April 2020 using MEDLINE, PubMed, Google Scholar, and Web of Science for all English-language medical ...
Existing literature reviews on social media and education emphasise the pedagogical use of specific applications and channels, such as wikis (Trocky & Buckley, Citation 2016), Twitter (Aydin, Citation 2014; Forgie et al., Citation 2013) or Facebook (Yang, Wang, Woo, & Quek, Citation 2011), and examine (improvement of) learning results.Although educational software, such as learning management ...
In this article, the authors present the results from a structured review of the literature, identifying and analyzing the most quoted and dominant definitions of social media (SM) and alternative terms that were used between 1994 and 2019 to identify their major applications. Similarities and differences in the definitions are highlighted to provide guidelines for researchers and managers who ...
Social media literacy is understood as the update of media literacy to perform more suitable analyses of such digital platforms, since they are at the interface between "social" and "media", which will enrich, expand, and update the important tradition of mass media education. 6. McLean et al., (2017) [53] Australia.
To date, while more and more studies acknowledge the potential value of social media in NPD, few systematically synthesize the literature on companies' social media use. 1 A systematic literature review is a methodical approach to summarize existing evidence, identify gaps, and suggest future research directions (Thomé et al., 2016).
The ubiquity of social media in contemporary society has sparked a growing body of research examining its effects on various aspects of life, including academic performance. This literature review aims to synthesise findings from recent studies (2018-present) on the impact of social media usage on academic performance.
Likewise, Mostafa (2015) defines social media as 'the usage of Web-based tools that link people and enable then to share information, videos, pictures, and so on'. In recent years, the use of SM ...
Rumor detection is an essential task in the era of social media, where the spread of false information can cause significant harm to an individual, society, and institutions. The purpose of rumor detection is to promote transparency, accuracy, and trustworthiness in information sharing, thereby contributing to the well-being and stability of communities and society as a whole. The main ...
Socially anxious (SA) and lonely (LO) individuals use social media to compensate for lacking in-person relationships. •. SA and LO individuals do not necessarily receive the support they seek online. •. Problematic social media use (SMU) is commonly defined in terms of high frequency and/or passive use. •.
Background: Selfie-related injury has become a public health concern amid the near ubiquitous use of smartphones and social media apps. Of particular concern are selfie-related deaths at aquatic locations; areas often frequented because of their photogenic allure. Unfortunately, such places exhibit hazards inherent with their environment. Objective: This study aimed to ascertain current ...
In the last decade, many publications have appeared on degrowth as a strategy to confront environmental and social problems. This column reviews their content, data, and methods. The authors conclude that a large majority of the studies are opinions rather than analysis, few studies use quantitative or qualitative data, and even fewer use formal modelling; the first and second type tend to ...
This paper reviews the relevant literature on social media to yield a better understanding of how it has transformed the way people communicate, acquire and use information. To elucidate on the ...
A mini literature review of AF patients presented with gastrointestinal (GI) tract bleeding. Research design: Case report and literature review. Data Collection: An electronic search of PubMed was performed from inception to December 2023. Results: 34 AF patients presented with GI tract bleeding were identified published in the literature. The ...